Difference between revisions of "Mark Master"
(Refine article category within site hierarchy) |
(Link Mark advancement with Mariner elevation and explain how the lodges are attached.) |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | =Mark Master | + | [[File:Arch and keystone - Britannica 1911.png|thumb|right|310px|alt=Cross-section of a masonry arch. The letter A identifies the wedge at the crown, between the stones rising from either side.|The keystone, marked '''A''', closes the arch at its crown. The same taper that makes the stone look wrong among rectangular blocks makes it right for this opening. ''Encyclopædia Britannica'' (1911), “Arch”, fig. 1.]] |
| + | The '''Mark Master Mason''' degree, also called '''Mark Master''' or simply '''the Mark''', tells the story of a stone rejected by the very builders who need it. The candidate takes the part of a [[Fellow Craft]] bringing work from the quarries for [[King Solomon]]’s Temple. The overseers discard an unfamiliar stone; when the builders need the keystone for an arch, they must search for the piece they threw away. The ceremony, called ''advancement'' in England and Wales, asks two questions: how can a craftsman show which work is his, and how can those who judge it recognise what it is worth?<ref name="cambs">Provincial Grand Lodge of Cambridgeshire, [https://pglcambs.org.uk/the-cambridgeshire-mason/23.pdf ''The Cambridgeshire Mason'', no. 23], pp. 10–11, especially “Set in stone” and “Ritual with flair”.</ref><ref name="essex">Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Essex, [https://www.essexmark.org.uk/an-introduction-to-mark.html An introduction to the degree of Mark Master Mason].</ref> | ||
| − | The | + | The story returns to the work of the second Craft degree, although in the English system the candidate is already a [[Master Mason]]. Whether the Mark also forms a step towards the [[Holy Royal Arch]] depends on the Masonic constitution: it does in Scotland and in the usual American York Rite sequence, while an English Master Mason may join the Royal Arch without taking the Mark.<ref name="mmh">Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, [https://markmasonshall.org/orders/mmm Mark Master Masons].</ref><ref name="sgc">Supreme Grand Chapter of England, [https://www.ugle.org.uk/about-us/royal-arch The Royal Arch].</ref><ref name="scot">Supreme Grand Royal Arch Chapter of Scotland, [https://sgrac-scotland.com/journey-to-the-royal-arch/ Journey to the Royal Arch], “Royal Arch Series”.</ref><ref name="florida">Grand York Rite of Florida, [https://grandyorkrite.org/chapter/degrees/ The capitular degrees].</ref> |
| − | The | + | == The ceremony of advancement == |
| + | In the English working described by the Province of Essex, the ceremony brings together two older stages. The candidate is first acknowledged as a ''Mark Man'' and then advanced as a ''Mark Master Mason''. The first stage gives him an identity as a workman: he chooses a mark by which his work can be known. The second puts his judgement and that of his superiors to the test. Three officers play the inspectors on the building site: the Junior, Senior and Master Overseers.<ref name="essex" /><ref name="cambs" /> | ||
| − | + | The Cambridgeshire account follows the stone from quarry to building site. The candidate presents a stone he has cut. The overseers do not recognise its use and throw it on the rubbish heap. The payment scene gives that rejection a consequence: a workman must establish his claim to wages. Later, work on the arch cannot be finished because its keystone is missing. The search leads back to the heap. Nothing about the stone has changed; what the builders now understand is where it belongs. The craftsman whose skill went unrecognised receives his due.<ref name="cambs" /><ref name="essex" /> | |
| − | + | Malcolm C. Duncan’s American ''Masonic Ritual and Monitor'' (1866) gives the candidate a different part. Asked who cut the unusual stone, he admits that he found it in the quarry. He nevertheless attempts to draw wages. The stone ultimately proves to be the work of [[Hiram Abiff]]. Here the overseers are wrong about its value, but right to ask who made it: bringing a fine piece to the building site does not entitle the finder to the maker’s pay. Duncan records one nineteenth-century working; this detail cannot simply be transferred to the English account.<ref name="duncan">Malcolm C. Duncan, ''Duncan’s Masonic Ritual and Monitor'' (1866), [https://archive.sacred-texts.com/mas/dun/dun05.htm Mark Master, or Fourth Degree], pp. 158–63 (inspection and wages), 170–74 (recovery, mark and tools).</ref> | |
| − | [[Category:Mark Masonry]] | + | <span id="Marks_and_public_symbolism"></span> |
| + | == The mason’s mark == | ||
| + | [[File:Mark Master tools - Duncan.png|thumb|right|250px|alt=An engraving of the Mark Master’s chisel and mallet, the two tools shown in Duncan’s American monitor.|The chisel and mallet in Duncan’s ''Monitor'' (1866), p. 173. Duncan compares the chisel’s action to education bringing out a person’s abilities, and the mallet’s to the discipline of governing one’s temper.]] | ||
| + | The personal mark serves much as a signature does. In the building legend it connects a stone to the person who shaped it: the overseers can credit good work and trace a fault back to its maker. In an English Mark lodge the Registrar of Marks records the design the candidate has chosen. He may subsequently use it alongside his name in a lodge register. The mark therefore carries a responsibility as well as a privilege: the craftsman stands by work that others can identify as his.<ref name="essex" /><ref name="cambs" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | A surviving mark book shows how personal the choice could be. Between 1815 and 1835, members of King Hiram Royal Arch Chapter in Greenwich Village, Massachusetts, recorded designs inside the same keystone outline and signed their entries. George Plumb’s design included a woman with an anchor, an emblem of hope, beneath an all-seeing eye. The keystone belonged to the degree; the design inside it identified Plumb. The [https://www.srmml.org/the-mark-book-a-way-to-remember-masons/ museum’s illustrated account] reproduces his entry.<ref>Catherine Swanson, [https://www.srmml.org/the-mark-book-a-way-to-remember-masons/ The Mark Book: A Way to Remember Masons], Scottish Rite Masonic Museum & Library (2008), collection MA 001.003.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Marks on actual medieval stonework require a different kind of reading. Architectural historian Jennifer S. Alexander distinguishes a mason’s working mark from an assembly mark, which tells builders how pieces fit together. Similar simple signs can turn up on unrelated buildings. A mark cut in a cathedral can tell us about the organisation of the building work; by itself it cannot identify its cutter as a member of the modern Masonic degree.<ref>Jennifer S. Alexander, [https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/arts/scapvc/arthistory/people/ja/research/masonsmarks/ Medieval masons’ marks], University of Warwick; extract from “Masons’ Marks and the Working Practices of Medieval Stone Masons”, in P. S. Barnwell and Arnold Pacey (eds.), ''Who Built Beverley Minster?'' (2008).</ref><ref name="prescott">Andrew Prescott, [https://www.markdgljmci.com.jm/wellMarked.shtml Well Marked: Approaches to the History of Mark Masonry], reproduced by the District Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Jamaica and Cayman Islands.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The rejected keystone == | ||
| + | A keystone is the wedge at the crown of an arch. Its sloping faces meet the stones on either side. A square is useful for inspecting an ordinary rectangular block, but it cannot tell an overseer whether this wedge is right for this arch. In Duncan’s account the first two inspectors notice the stone’s fine workmanship even as they hesitate over its shape. The mistake is understandable, which gives the reversal its force: judging the piece requires knowing the design of the whole building.<ref name="archfig">[https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/1911_Encyclop%C3%A6dia_Britannica/Arch “Arch”], ''Encyclopædia Britannica'', 11th ed., vol. 2 (1911), p. 342, fig. 1.</ref><ref name="duncan" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Psalm 118:22 supplies the image of reversal: “The stone which the builders refused is become the head stone of the corner.” Duncan has the Master read this verse when the discarded stone is recovered, followed by its echoes in the Gospels. The psalm speaks of the head of the '''corner'''; the ceremony stages that reversal with the stone at the '''crown of an arch'''. The verse explains why the rejection matters. It is not a biblical account of a keystone going missing at Solomon’s Temple.<ref>[https://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Psalms-118-22/ Psalm 118:22], King James Version; see also Matthew 21:42, Mark 12:10 and Luke 20:17.</ref><ref name="duncan" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == From Fellow Craft to the Holy Royal Arch == | ||
| + | The [[Fellow Craft#The winding stairs and the wages|Fellow Craft lecture]] brings the workman to the Middle Chamber to receive his wages. The Mark returns to the moment ''before'' payment: someone must inspect the work and decide whose labour it represents. The candidate now experiences the other side of a familiar tool. As a Fellow Craft he learns to use the square; in the Mark story he stands before the men who use it to judge the stone he brings.<ref>Grand Lodge of Maine, [https://www.mainemason.org/resources/masonic-instructors-manual/fellowcraft/ Fellowcraft], ''Masonic Instructor’s Manual''.</ref><ref name="duncan" /><ref name="essex" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The [[Holy Royal Arch#How the lost Word is recovered|Royal Arch account of the lost Word]] tells a later Temple story. In the Mark the builders retrieve a piece needed to finish the first Temple. In exaltation the returning exiles work amongst the ruins long after that Temple’s destruction. Their discovery in a vault answers the loss of sacred knowledge in the [[Master Mason]] degree. The Mark can prepare a reader to recognise the pattern of recovery, but finding a piece of stone and recovering [[The Lost Word|the Word]] are different events. The Scottish ceremonies make the narrative link especially close: the vault built during the Mark is the one rediscovered in the Royal Arch.<ref name="scot" /><ref name="sgc" /><ref name="florida" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Differences between jurisdictions == | ||
| + | * '''England and Wales.''' A Master Mason takes the Mark in a separate Mark lodge. The story goes back to the Fellow Craft at work before Hiram’s death. Membership of the Mark is optional for a Master Mason seeking exaltation in an English Royal Arch chapter.<ref name="mmh" /><ref name="essex" /><ref name="sgc" /> | ||
| + | * '''Scotland.''' Under the 1860 agreement, a Master Mason may receive the Mark in his Craft lodge or in a Mark lodge attached to a Royal Arch chapter. The two workings are mutually recognised. A Mason who took the Mark in his Craft lodge and wishes to proceed to the Royal Arch affiliates to the chapter’s Mark lodge. The Scottish sequence is '''Mark Master Mason, Excellent Master, Royal Arch'''.<ref name="scot" /> | ||
| + | * '''United States.''' In the York Rite arrangement described by the Grand York Rite of Florida the Mark is the first ''capitular'' degree, meaning the first conferred by a chapter. The sequence is '''Mark Master, Past Master, Most Excellent Master, Royal Arch Mason'''. Here the Mark is part of the route to the Royal Arch; it is not an extra degree in the Craft lodge.<ref name="florida" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == The Royal Ark Mariner connection == | ||
| + | An English Mark Master Mason may also seek [[Royal Ark Mariner#The ceremony of elevation|elevation in a Royal Ark Mariner lodge]]. The Mariner lodge is attached, or ''moored'', to a Mark lodge and takes its number, but it tells an earlier biblical story. The Mark candidate brings stonework for inspection at Solomon’s Temple; the Mariner learns how Noah’s work in timber shelters a household and living creatures from the flood. See [[Royal Ark Mariner#Relationship to Mark Master Masonry|how the two lodges are related]].<ref>Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, [https://www.markmasonshall.org/orders/ram Royal Ark Mariner], on elevation and the mooring of lodges.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Historical records == | ||
| + | A minute of the Chapter of Friendship at Portsmouth records Thomas Dunckerley conferring the Mark on 1 September 1769. It says that he had already received it: the entry establishes an English working on that date, without establishing who devised it. The fact that a Royal Arch chapter held that meeting is itself evidence of an early connection, well before English Mark Masonry acquired its separate governing body.<ref>Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, Hampshire and Isle of Wight, [https://hants-iow-mark.org/the-history-of-mark-masonry-in-hampshire-isle-of-wight/ The history of Mark Masonry in Hampshire & Isle of Wight].</ref><ref>Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Devonshire, [https://devonmarkmasons.co.uk/information/provincial-history/pre-grand-lodge-days Pre Grand Lodge Days], quoting the Portsmouth minute.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | The English Mark Grand Lodge was established in 1856. Historian Andrew Prescott places its creation in the disputes over Masonic government in the 1850s and cautions against explaining it solely as a consequence of the English Craft union of 1813. Some existing Mark lodges joined the new body later; the description ''Time Immemorial'' recognises that they predated its foundation.<ref name="prescott" /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Film: The Magic of the Mark == | ||
| + | ''The Magic of the Mark'' is Mark Masons’ Hall’s introduction to the order in England and Wales. It gives the order’s own perspective on membership and its charitable work. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jategsI50bY Watch on YouTube].<ref>Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of North Wales, [https://northwalesmark.co.uk/ The Magic of the Mark], film introduction.</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | <youtube width="560" height="315">jategsI50bY</youtube> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == References == | ||
| + | <references /> | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{Topic navigation}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Category:Royal Arch and Mark Masonry]] | ||
Latest revision as of 17:44, 10 November 2026
The Mark Master Mason degree, also called Mark Master or simply the Mark, tells the story of a stone rejected by the very builders who need it. The candidate takes the part of a Fellow Craft bringing work from the quarries for King Solomon’s Temple. The overseers discard an unfamiliar stone; when the builders need the keystone for an arch, they must search for the piece they threw away. The ceremony, called advancement in England and Wales, asks two questions: how can a craftsman show which work is his, and how can those who judge it recognise what it is worth?[1][2]
The story returns to the work of the second Craft degree, although in the English system the candidate is already a Master Mason. Whether the Mark also forms a step towards the Holy Royal Arch depends on the Masonic constitution: it does in Scotland and in the usual American York Rite sequence, while an English Master Mason may join the Royal Arch without taking the Mark.[3][4][5][6]
The ceremony of advancement
In the English working described by the Province of Essex, the ceremony brings together two older stages. The candidate is first acknowledged as a Mark Man and then advanced as a Mark Master Mason. The first stage gives him an identity as a workman: he chooses a mark by which his work can be known. The second puts his judgement and that of his superiors to the test. Three officers play the inspectors on the building site: the Junior, Senior and Master Overseers.[2][1]
The Cambridgeshire account follows the stone from quarry to building site. The candidate presents a stone he has cut. The overseers do not recognise its use and throw it on the rubbish heap. The payment scene gives that rejection a consequence: a workman must establish his claim to wages. Later, work on the arch cannot be finished because its keystone is missing. The search leads back to the heap. Nothing about the stone has changed; what the builders now understand is where it belongs. The craftsman whose skill went unrecognised receives his due.[1][2]
Malcolm C. Duncan’s American Masonic Ritual and Monitor (1866) gives the candidate a different part. Asked who cut the unusual stone, he admits that he found it in the quarry. He nevertheless attempts to draw wages. The stone ultimately proves to be the work of Hiram Abiff. Here the overseers are wrong about its value, but right to ask who made it: bringing a fine piece to the building site does not entitle the finder to the maker’s pay. Duncan records one nineteenth-century working; this detail cannot simply be transferred to the English account.[7]
The mason’s mark
The personal mark serves much as a signature does. In the building legend it connects a stone to the person who shaped it: the overseers can credit good work and trace a fault back to its maker. In an English Mark lodge the Registrar of Marks records the design the candidate has chosen. He may subsequently use it alongside his name in a lodge register. The mark therefore carries a responsibility as well as a privilege: the craftsman stands by work that others can identify as his.[2][1]
A surviving mark book shows how personal the choice could be. Between 1815 and 1835, members of King Hiram Royal Arch Chapter in Greenwich Village, Massachusetts, recorded designs inside the same keystone outline and signed their entries. George Plumb’s design included a woman with an anchor, an emblem of hope, beneath an all-seeing eye. The keystone belonged to the degree; the design inside it identified Plumb. The museum’s illustrated account reproduces his entry.[8]
Marks on actual medieval stonework require a different kind of reading. Architectural historian Jennifer S. Alexander distinguishes a mason’s working mark from an assembly mark, which tells builders how pieces fit together. Similar simple signs can turn up on unrelated buildings. A mark cut in a cathedral can tell us about the organisation of the building work; by itself it cannot identify its cutter as a member of the modern Masonic degree.[9][10]
The rejected keystone
A keystone is the wedge at the crown of an arch. Its sloping faces meet the stones on either side. A square is useful for inspecting an ordinary rectangular block, but it cannot tell an overseer whether this wedge is right for this arch. In Duncan’s account the first two inspectors notice the stone’s fine workmanship even as they hesitate over its shape. The mistake is understandable, which gives the reversal its force: judging the piece requires knowing the design of the whole building.[11][7]
Psalm 118:22 supplies the image of reversal: “The stone which the builders refused is become the head stone of the corner.” Duncan has the Master read this verse when the discarded stone is recovered, followed by its echoes in the Gospels. The psalm speaks of the head of the corner; the ceremony stages that reversal with the stone at the crown of an arch. The verse explains why the rejection matters. It is not a biblical account of a keystone going missing at Solomon’s Temple.[12][7]
From Fellow Craft to the Holy Royal Arch
The Fellow Craft lecture brings the workman to the Middle Chamber to receive his wages. The Mark returns to the moment before payment: someone must inspect the work and decide whose labour it represents. The candidate now experiences the other side of a familiar tool. As a Fellow Craft he learns to use the square; in the Mark story he stands before the men who use it to judge the stone he brings.[13][7][2]
The Royal Arch account of the lost Word tells a later Temple story. In the Mark the builders retrieve a piece needed to finish the first Temple. In exaltation the returning exiles work amongst the ruins long after that Temple’s destruction. Their discovery in a vault answers the loss of sacred knowledge in the Master Mason degree. The Mark can prepare a reader to recognise the pattern of recovery, but finding a piece of stone and recovering the Word are different events. The Scottish ceremonies make the narrative link especially close: the vault built during the Mark is the one rediscovered in the Royal Arch.[5][4][6]
Differences between jurisdictions
- England and Wales. A Master Mason takes the Mark in a separate Mark lodge. The story goes back to the Fellow Craft at work before Hiram’s death. Membership of the Mark is optional for a Master Mason seeking exaltation in an English Royal Arch chapter.[3][2][4]
- Scotland. Under the 1860 agreement, a Master Mason may receive the Mark in his Craft lodge or in a Mark lodge attached to a Royal Arch chapter. The two workings are mutually recognised. A Mason who took the Mark in his Craft lodge and wishes to proceed to the Royal Arch affiliates to the chapter’s Mark lodge. The Scottish sequence is Mark Master Mason, Excellent Master, Royal Arch.[5]
- United States. In the York Rite arrangement described by the Grand York Rite of Florida the Mark is the first capitular degree, meaning the first conferred by a chapter. The sequence is Mark Master, Past Master, Most Excellent Master, Royal Arch Mason. Here the Mark is part of the route to the Royal Arch; it is not an extra degree in the Craft lodge.[6]
The Royal Ark Mariner connection
An English Mark Master Mason may also seek elevation in a Royal Ark Mariner lodge. The Mariner lodge is attached, or moored, to a Mark lodge and takes its number, but it tells an earlier biblical story. The Mark candidate brings stonework for inspection at Solomon’s Temple; the Mariner learns how Noah’s work in timber shelters a household and living creatures from the flood. See how the two lodges are related.[14]
Historical records
A minute of the Chapter of Friendship at Portsmouth records Thomas Dunckerley conferring the Mark on 1 September 1769. It says that he had already received it: the entry establishes an English working on that date, without establishing who devised it. The fact that a Royal Arch chapter held that meeting is itself evidence of an early connection, well before English Mark Masonry acquired its separate governing body.[15][16]
The English Mark Grand Lodge was established in 1856. Historian Andrew Prescott places its creation in the disputes over Masonic government in the 1850s and cautions against explaining it solely as a consequence of the English Craft union of 1813. Some existing Mark lodges joined the new body later; the description Time Immemorial recognises that they predated its foundation.[10]
Film: The Magic of the Mark
The Magic of the Mark is Mark Masons’ Hall’s introduction to the order in England and Wales. It gives the order’s own perspective on membership and its charitable work. Watch on YouTube.[17]
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Provincial Grand Lodge of Cambridgeshire, The Cambridgeshire Mason, no. 23, pp. 10–11, especially “Set in stone” and “Ritual with flair”.
- ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Essex, An introduction to the degree of Mark Master Mason.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, Mark Master Masons.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Supreme Grand Chapter of England, The Royal Arch.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 Supreme Grand Royal Arch Chapter of Scotland, Journey to the Royal Arch, “Royal Arch Series”.
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 6.2 Grand York Rite of Florida, The capitular degrees.
- ↑ 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 Malcolm C. Duncan, Duncan’s Masonic Ritual and Monitor (1866), Mark Master, or Fourth Degree, pp. 158–63 (inspection and wages), 170–74 (recovery, mark and tools).
- ↑ Catherine Swanson, The Mark Book: A Way to Remember Masons, Scottish Rite Masonic Museum & Library (2008), collection MA 001.003.
- ↑ Jennifer S. Alexander, Medieval masons’ marks, University of Warwick; extract from “Masons’ Marks and the Working Practices of Medieval Stone Masons”, in P. S. Barnwell and Arnold Pacey (eds.), Who Built Beverley Minster? (2008).
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 Andrew Prescott, Well Marked: Approaches to the History of Mark Masonry, reproduced by the District Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Jamaica and Cayman Islands.
- ↑ “Arch”, Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th ed., vol. 2 (1911), p. 342, fig. 1.
- ↑ Psalm 118:22, King James Version; see also Matthew 21:42, Mark 12:10 and Luke 20:17.
- ↑ Grand Lodge of Maine, Fellowcraft, Masonic Instructor’s Manual.
- ↑ Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, Royal Ark Mariner, on elevation and the mooring of lodges.
- ↑ Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons, Hampshire and Isle of Wight, The history of Mark Masonry in Hampshire & Isle of Wight.
- ↑ Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of Devonshire, Pre Grand Lodge Days, quoting the Portsmouth minute.
- ↑ Provincial Grand Lodge of Mark Master Masons of North Wales, The Magic of the Mark, film introduction.
| Explore the Freemasonry Wiki: Full article index · All articles · All categories · Random article |