Antients and Moderns

From Freemasonry Wiki
Revision as of 10:50, 30 September 2026 by User (talk | contribs) (Link the Premier Grand Lodge to its formation history)
Engraved frontispiece beside the printed title page of the 1723 Constitutions.
Frontispiece and title page of The Constitutions of the Free-Masons (1723), compiled by James Anderson.

Antients and Moderns were the names used for two rival English Grand Lodges that coexisted from 1751 until their union in 1813. The older organisation, conventionally dated to 1717 and often called the Premier Grand Lodge, acquired the label Moderns from its opponents. The Grand Lodge established in 1751 called itself Antient, claiming to preserve older practice. Their union on 27 December 1813 created the United Grand Lodge of England.[1]

The names and the rivalry

The labels expressed a disagreement about Masonic practice, rather than the relative ages of the organisations. The Antients included Irish and Scottish Freemasons living in London who were dissatisfied with the existing Grand Lodge. Both organisations subsequently governed lodges in Britain and overseas, while disputing one another's regularity.[1]

Laurence Dermott, the Antients' Grand Secretary, helped develop their administration and provision of charitable relief. The system of warrants, membership certificates and lodge rules supported an expanding organisation, including lodges serving soldiers and sailors overseas.[2]

The disagreement also appeared in print. Dermott compiled Ahiman Rezon, first published in 1756 as the Antients' book of constitutions. Its later illustrated editions asserted the body's antiquity and its connections with Ireland and Scotland. The Moderns continued their own series of constitutions, beginning with The 1723 Constitutions. These publications record how each organisation presented its authority; their historical claims need to be read in the context of the rivalry.[3]

The Royal Arch and the union

The place of the Royal Arch was a substantial point of disagreement. The Antients treated it as integral to their system of Craft Masonry, while the Moderns' Grand Lodge did not accord it the same recognition. This was a dispute about the boundaries and government of Masonry as well as about practice.[4]

The Dukes of Kent and Sussex, the respective Grand Masters at the time of union, brought the two organisations together in 1813.[2] The agreed declaration recognised three Craft degrees while including the Holy Royal Arch. That formulation survives in the English Book of Constitutions. Under the resulting English arrangement, the Craft is governed by the United Grand Lodge and the Royal Arch by Supreme Grand Chapter; this relationship should not be assumed to describe every Masonic jurisdiction.[5]

The union was followed by standardisation of practice, administration and regalia.[1] The signed Articles of Union are among the historical documents held by the Museum of Freemasonry in London.[6]

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 United Grand Lodge of England, History of Freemasonry, entries for 1717, 1751 and 1813. Accessed 24 September 2026.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Rob Soames, Laurence Dermott - Enigma and Trailblazer, United Grand Lodge of England, 12 January 2021. Accessed 24 September 2026.
  3. ↑ Museum of Freemasonry, An illustrated rivalry. Accessed 24 September 2026.
  4. ↑ Jim Daniel, Stuck with the Sussex fudge?, United Grand Lodge of England, 12 January 2021. Accessed 24 September 2026.
  5. ↑ United Grand Lodge of England, Discover More about the Royal Arch, 22 September 2023. Accessed 24 September 2026.
  6. ↑ Museum of Freemasonry, Three centuries of English freemasonry. Accessed 24 September 2026.

Early Masonic history

Chronology: Timeline of early Freemasonry

Documents: The Old Charges · The Regius manuscript · The Cooke manuscript · The Schaw Statutes · The St Clair Charters · The 1723 Constitutions

Scottish lodges and ideas: William Schaw · Early Scottish lodges · Lodge Mother Kilwinning · Mary's Chapel · Canongate Kilwinning · Haughfoot Lodge · Operative and speculative Freemasonry · The art of memory and Freemasonry · Freemasonry and the Royal Society · The Templar theory of Masonic origins

People: Robert Moray · John Theophilus Desaguliers · James Anderson · William Preston · Andrew Michael Ramsay

Chivalric systems: The Strict Observance · Karl Gotthelf von Hund · Lyon (1778) · Wilhelmsbad (1782) · Jean-Baptiste Willermoz · Rectified Scottish Rite

English Grand Lodges: Formation of the first Grand Lodge · Antients and Moderns · Laurence Dermott · Ahiman Rezon · The Union of 1813

Ireland, Scotland and overseas: Early Irish Freemasonry · Grand Lodge of Scotland · Military and travelling lodges

France and the Jacobites: Early French Freemasonry · Freemasonry and the Jacobites

Atlantic connections: Benjamin Franklin · The Lodge of the Nine Sisters · George Washington · Paul Revere · African Lodge No. 459 · Prince Hall

Research: Sources for studying early Freemasonry · Masonic museums and libraries

Explore the Freemasonry Wiki: Full article index · All articles · All categories · Random article